Federal prosecutors handling the murder of 18-year-old Anna Kepner aboard a Carnival cruise ship now face a wild new complication.

Investigators recently revealed that DNA from an unidentified male minor was also recovered during the probe, igniting renewed debate and speculation about what really happened aboard the Carnival Horizon last November.

According to a newly unsealed transcript of a 145-page detention hearing, the FBI obtained DNA from this mystery boy, who allegedly had sex with Kepner during the voyage.

The revelation came as prosecutors continued building their case against Kepner’s stepbrother, 16-year-old Timothy Hudson, accused of sexually assaulting and murdering her during the cruise.

Here's What They're Not Telling You About Your Retirement

Kepner was discovered dead in the cabin she shared with Hudson and her younger brother as the ship sailed from Cozumel to Miami.

Officials claim that key forensic evidence points directly to Hudson, but this new DNA twist threatens to muddy the waters.

It presents the defense with a potential avenue to challenge the government’s timeline and evidence handling.

Prosecutors asserted that two separate vaginal swabs collected from Kepner’s autopsy contained male DNA, one testing positive for sperm.

FREE Gun Law Map: Laws Don't Pause During Social Unrest

That prompted federal authorities to order DNA samples from both Hudson and the second minor who reportedly had intercourse with the victim.

Forensics later concluded that Hudson’s DNA was overwhelmingly consistent with the genetic material found, while the other boy was excluded as a possible contributor.

Prosecutors told the court that one DNA sample was calculated to be one hundred twenty sextillion times more likely to have come from Hudson rather than an unknown man.

Another swab, without sperm but positive for male DNA, was said to be 1.2 septillion times more likely to include Hudson.

Those astronomical figures, investigators said, left very little room for coincidence.

Still, Hudson’s defense did not back down.

His lawyer pushed the FBI agent on whether the medical examiner could determine the time between intercourse and death or prove the same person was responsible for both acts.

The agent admitted he did not believe such a clear determination had been made.

That response gave the defense ammunition to argue that prosecutors may be making leaps without direct proof.

WATCH:

The defense also hinted that the sexual contact involving the out-of-state teenager could become a central question for the jury, especially if it shows other interactions with Kepner shortly before her death.

They emphasized that proximity and DNA alone do not prove murder, and that investigators must fully account for every contact she had while aboard the ship.

Federal prosecutors countered that all evidence continues to indicate Hudson played a central role.

They presented a collection of surveillance footage, digital data, and cabin access records that together paint a troubling picture.

According to the government, Kepner was last seen entering her cabin around 7:38 p.m. on November 6 and was never spotted leaving.

Video later showed Hudson exiting at intervals consistent with when she likely died.

Investigators said Hudson’s phone data revealed movements consistent with the time frame of the murder and destruction of evidence.

Kepner’s own phone was later found smashed and discarded in a trash bin along what prosecutors described as Hudson’s trail through the ship.

The government is also said to possess footage that helped pin down that sequence of events.

Despite the evidence, the presiding judge stated that while probable cause existed for the charges, he would not go so far as to call the case overwhelming.

He said the evidence made for “a much closer call” and left open the possibility that multiple defenses could be raised once the trial begins.

That cautious statement has fueled talk that the prosecution may face a tougher fight than first assumed.

Outrage spread on social media when Hudson was allowed to remain free pending trial, with critics arguing that someone accused of such heinous acts should not be walking the streets.

Friends and relatives of Kepner voiced their frustration, saying their family has been through a nightmare that only keeps getting worse.

Kepner’s father previously told reporters that he found his daughter’s body shoved under the bed inside their cabin, calling the memory “too painful to relive again.”

The case has gained national attention, not only for its grotesque details but also for how it exposes the chaotic inner workings of cruise ship investigations.

Federal authorities have jurisdiction, but the setting complicates every step of evidence gathering, jurisdiction, and chain of custody.

The result is often an investigative maze that leaves families devastated and the public demanding answers.

Hudson faces the possibility of life imprisonment if convicted.

His defense team continues to challenge the validity and timing of the evidence, seeking to build reasonable doubt around when and how the fatal assault occurred.

Prosecutors, for their part, remain confident that the combination of DNA, video evidence, and digital tracking will hold firm in court.

The trial is expected to begin in September, and all sides are bracing for a sensational courtroom battle.

For now, the headline-grabbing revelation of another male’s DNA on the victim has only deepened the mystery of what truly happened aboard the Carnival Horizon.

The government may think it has its suspect, but the defense appears ready to fight every inch of the way as this disturbing case pushes forward.

Warning: Account balances and purchasing power no longer tell the same story. Know in 2 minutes if your retirement is working for you.